top of page

The problem with the modern-day Peterborough United footballer

2 minutes ago
6 min read


Has the hunger gone? Has the pride disappeared? Or have we reached a point where playing for Peterborough United is just another job?


There was a time when being a professional footballer meant something different, not necessarily because players were more talented, fitter or technically gifted than they are today.


The modern footballer has benefits that previous generations could only have dreamt of, but there was something different about the mentality of footballers in years gone by, they truly loved the game and understood what it meant to represent a football club.


As I sit here now, looking at Posh, I have to wonder whether some of that has been lost.


My biggest concern isn't necessarily results, performances or even the league position, it's whether enough of the players genuinely care about our football club.



When football was more than just a job


Think back to the Posh sides of years gone by (worse in the 80s gang, I am looking at you here).


Think of the players that dragged us through difficult afternoons and evenings, who understood the expectations of the supporters and who seemed genuinely obsessed with the game they were fortunate enough to play professionally.


They made mistakes, had poor games, and sometimes let themselves down (let’s not pretend footballers of previous generations were all tucked up in bed at nine o’clock on a Saturday with a glass of water). 


But one thing you could never deny about these groups of players was the hunger and desire that they had.


They were players who wanted to play at the highest possible level, and who understood that Peterborough United could be the beginning of something special, but that getting there required sacrifice.


There was an ambition to improve, an obsession with football and a determination to make the most of what was, for many, a relatively short career.


You felt that football mattered to them beyond the 90 minutes on a Saturday afternoon.

Can we honestly say the same about everyone representing Peterborough United today?


The Saturday night culture


There are stories circulating about Peterborough United players heading out for drinks on Saturday nights, and more concerningly, in recent times, there have been accounts of players being spotted out the night before matches.


It's important to distinguish between stories and established facts. Being seen out doesn't automatically mean someone has been drinking excessively, behaving unprofessionally or breaking club rules.


Nobody is suggesting that professional footballers should be locked inside their homes, unable to enjoy a social life. They're human beings and they deserve time away from their jobs just like the rest of us.


But when you're representing a football club that thousands of people spend their hard-earned money supporting, surely there has to be an expectation that your preparation is beyond question. 


If you're going out drinking regularly during the season, is that really the mentality of somebody determined to maximise their potential? If you're out late before a game, are you giving yourself the best possible chance of performing? If the performances on the pitch aren't good enough, surely those questions become even more relevant.


It is often said that football is a short career, would it not be more appropriate for footballers to give this career its full attention, knowing that if they succeed, they will have years to enjoy all things outside of football?


Do they even love football?


This, for me, is perhaps the most frustrating part of the modern game. There is a growing perception that some professional footballers don't actually have much interest in football outside of playing it.


They don't spend their evenings watching matches. They don't appear particularly interested in studying players in their positions. They don't seem obsessed with understanding tactics, movement or the tiny details that separate average footballers from exceptional ones.


Of course, we can't know exactly what every player does in their spare time but it raises a question worth asking. How can you expect to reach the highest level of your profession if you aren't genuinely interested in learning everything you possibly can about it?


Imagine being a central midfielder at Posh. You have access to more football than any previous generation. Every major league, every elite midfielder in world football is available to study at the touch of a button. 


Yet how many of our players are genuinely taking advantage of that opportunity, or even go home after training and spend an hour analysing their own performance? 


Where is the fear of failure?


Perhaps the biggest change in modern football, particularly at clubs like Posh, is the financial safety net. Years ago, failing to establish yourself in the Football League would have had serious consequences for your career.


With the money invested in the pyramid now though, the risk of not succeeding is not that high. Take my friend Abraham Odoh for example, he had a relatively successful first season at Posh (given who he was replacing), then an absolute disaster second season, but is now most likely earning more at Salford than he did at Posh.


I feel now that it’s easier to accept mediocrity, and sometimes even worse. It’s unfair to say that all players think this way, but right now, Peterborough United need more players who look like the prospect of failure hurts them.


Fighting for your career takes you to another level, we have seen it with players like Kyrell Lisbie who was absolutely ravenous to succeed, but where the fight is lacking, complacency can easily set in.


The club has a responsibility too


Posh have built their identity in the Darragh MacAnthony era on developing players and selling them on to fees. For many good players with potential, a move to Posh will always be considered a stepping stone. 


However, just because the club can be a stepping stone, doesn’t mean the players can’t form strong emotional ties to Posh and the fans during their time with us. 


As fans, we don’t see us as a ‘selling club’ and we certainly will never move onwards and upwards from following the club. While it would be unreasonable for us to expect players to care as much as the fans, the hierarchy needs to make it clear how important it is to respect our love for the club.


The ‘you will become a millionaire’ line is an effective one to lure lower league players, with several options, to London Road, however the club need to make it clear that the primary goal while at the club is to make us fans proud. 


Peterborough United must have standards on the way players conduct themselves on and off the pitch, and as a club we have to be willing to call it out when these standards are not met. 


When standards drop across the board, even a little bit, the club can begin to rot from the inside, which I believe is what we have seen across the past two and a half years. 


It is not a sudden process, the eroding of a club from the inside, however we are miles away from the high standards of 2023/24, and while we don’t have the players on the pitch to meet the footballing standards, we can certainly enforce discipline and a necessity to apply maximum effort off it.



Give us something to believe in


I am not stupid. I know that the EFL is only getting more competitive, and that Posh are not going to win every week. I am not just a disgruntled fan moaning about results, because that is ultimately not what matters to me. 


What matters is seeing a group of players who are giving their all, devastated when we all lose and elated when we all win together. I want to see a group of players who show that they feel that playing for Peterborough United is an opportunity worth sacrificing for. 


Maybe I am guilty at times of romanticising footballers of the past, and maybe it is simply a different game these days, but I refuse to believe that genuine love for the game is an outdated concept.


I am not asking for Peterborough United players to pretend to be lifelong Posh supporters, I am just asking that they are desperate to be the best possible versions of themselves. 


If we fall short, but we have given it everything, then fine. But if representing this club is simply another job, and failure is met with indifference, then maybe we have uncovered one of the biggest problems facing Posh players in the modern day. 


As fans, we still live and breathe Peterborough United, and perhaps more crucially, the beautiful game of football. 


I think it is time the players showed us that they feel the same in the battle that lies ahead.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page